Peregrine Financial: The $215 Million Fraud Hidden with a Printer and Photoshop

by

Russell Wasendorf Sr. ran Peregrine Financial Group, a respected Iowa-based futures brokerage, for over 20 years while secretly stealing more than $215 million from customer accounts. The fraud was remarkably low-tech: Wasendorf intercepted bank statements, forged them using Photoshop and a laser printer, and presented the doctored statements to auditors and regulators. When the scheme was finally uncovered in July 2012, it stunned the futures industry and exposed catastrophic gaps in regulatory oversight that allowed a single individual to steal from customers for two decades.

Building a Reputation

Wasendorf founded Peregrine Financial Group, also known as PFGBest, in 1990 in Cedar Falls, Iowa. He built the firm into a mid-sized futures commission merchant with over 20,000 customer accounts and approximately $400 million in customer funds. Wasendorf cultivated an image as a successful, community-minded businessman. He built an impressive headquarters building, published a trading magazine, and was active in industry organizations. PFGBest was considered a reputable firm, and its location in a small Iowa city far from Wall Street seemed to reinforce the notion of heartland integrity.

The Forgery Operation

The mechanics of Wasendorf’s fraud were shockingly simple. Peregrine’s customer funds were held at U.S. Bank, and the firm was required to provide regulators with bank statements confirming the balances. Wasendorf set up a post office box that intercepted the genuine bank statements before they reached Peregrine’s offices. He then created forged versions using Adobe Photoshop and a color laser printer, altering the account balances to show hundreds of millions of dollars more than the accounts actually contained. He presented these forged statements to Peregrine’s auditors and to the National Futures Association, the industry’s self-regulatory organization.

Two Decades of Theft

Wasendorf later admitted in a signed confession that the fraud had been ongoing since the early 1990s. Over approximately 20 years, he systematically transferred customer funds to accounts he controlled and used the money to fund his personal lifestyle, business investments, and the construction of Peregrine’s headquarters. The total amount stolen exceeded $215 million. Throughout this period, Peregrine passed regulatory examinations and audits because the NFA relied on the bank statements that Wasendorf had personally forged.

The Failed Suicide and Discovery

On July 9, 2012, Wasendorf attempted suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning in his car outside Peregrine’s headquarters. He survived and was found with a signed confession detailing the fraud. In the confession, he wrote that he had been committing fraud for almost 20 years and described the forgery process in detail. He expressed surprise that the fraud had continued for so long without detection. The NFA immediately froze Peregrine’s accounts and discovered that the firm had approximately $220 million less in customer funds than its records showed.

Regulatory Failure

The Peregrine case exposed devastating weaknesses in futures industry regulation. The NFA had conducted regular examinations of Peregrine for two decades without detecting the fraud because it relied on paper bank statements provided by the firm itself rather than independently confirming balances directly with the bank. This was in stark contrast to the securities industry, where FINRA and the SEC required independent verification of customer fund balances. The failure was particularly embarrassing because it came just months after the MF Global collapse had already raised questions about the safety of customer funds in the futures industry.

Regulatory Reforms

In the aftermath, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the NFA implemented sweeping reforms to customer fund protection. The NFA began requiring firms to provide daily electronic confirmations of customer fund balances directly from banks, eliminating the ability of a single individual to forge paper statements. The CFTC enhanced its auditing procedures and increased the frequency of examinations of futures commission merchants. These reforms were widely seen as changes that should have been implemented years earlier but were catalyzed by the combined shock of MF Global and Peregrine.

Sentencing

Wasendorf pleaded guilty to mail fraud, two counts of lying to federal regulators, and embezzlement. In January 2013, he was sentenced to 50 years in federal prison, effectively a life sentence for the then-64-year-old. The judge noted the extraordinary duration and simplicity of the fraud, calling it remarkable that Wasendorf had been able to steal from customers for so long using nothing more sophisticated than a P.O. box and a printer. Customer claims exceeded the firm’s remaining assets, and the bankruptcy trustee spent years recovering funds and making distributions to affected customers.

Legacy

The Peregrine case is studied as an example of how regulatory complacency can enable even unsophisticated fraud to persist for decades. The simple lesson is that trusting regulated entities to self-report their compliance is not sufficient. Independent verification, electronic confirmation, and direct communication with custodial banks are essential safeguards that were absent in the futures industry until Peregrine’s collapse forced their adoption. The case also demonstrates that fraud does not require complex financial engineering. Sometimes the most damaging schemes rely on nothing more than trust, routine, and a color printer.

Related Articles

Related Articles

Related Articles